The Health Care Special
Rationing of Healthcare & Obama’s PayGo: Will These Work?
It was good to hear on 05/11 that Obama wants to bring back Paygo. You know, buying stuff when you have the money on hand to pay for it. Not on credit. If Congress spends money, they have to have it on hand like you and I do. The other good news is that we got 65 billion dollars coming back to our Treasury from the TARP bank payback. Now we are only 10 and ½ trillion down. Not counting the 1-2 trillion more for health care.
No matter, if you are watching the health care reform battle you need to examine two articles to put things in perspective. One is an excellent editorial in the Monday (June 8th) WALL STREET JOURNAL on the cost of the program. How are we going to pay for this monstrosity? I leave that for you to read as it is quite detailed. We will review the article by Dr. David Gratzer from the Tuesday June 9th issue in the OPINION section.
This man was born and raised in Canada but now works at the Manhattan Institute as a senior fellow. He writes of what he knows, and what will happen to US medicine if the government gets its way. Just like Canada. His revelation is not good news.
You may have seen some of the talking heads debating health care reform recently. They are all over the place and most don’t know what they are talking about. Like one blond woman I saw a few days ago saying how great competition with Medicare would be for health care. Medicare and private health insurance should compete to lower costs. Right. Medicare and Medicaid programs pay so little now that a doctor can’t run an office. The administrative overhead for them is about 1/3rd of the expenditures. Hospitals go bankrupt because they pay so well. How can hospitals pay staff and get the needed money to buy the new technology we all demand?
Paul Kanjorski (D, Pa.) had a local conference call in my area about health care reform. One lady asked about him rationing of health care. He said: never; won’t happen. This is just a scare tactic others use to worry folks. Well, read what Dr. Gratzer has to say. You should review the whole article on your own. I just make a few of his points.
Rationing is a method the government uses in Canada to cut their health care budget. Restrict access and you cut your budget. Care is reduced. Wait long enough and the really sick will die of or go elsewhere at their own cost. Approved procedures are put on a list. Some things can’t be done. They aren’t on the list. Dialysis for those over the age of 55 years is not provided. If you have renal failure, your life is not worth anything. You have long, long, long waiting lists. So long that your brain tumor will kill you before you get care. People go to the US for emergency brain surgery, broken necks and so on because they have significant shortages of doctors. You wait to see a specialist and to have a CT scan—up to a year or more. The poor in socialized medicine actually get worse care and are less healthy than here in the US—even with 47 million uninsured.
If it’s so great in Canada, the UK, Australia and New Zealand, why do I have so many foreign doctor friends who emigrated here???? Why are they going back to private practice and opening private hospitals in England and Canada?? Yeah, it’s free. Sort of. Taxes are a killer but you need to remember: you get what you pay for.
So Dr. Gratzer’s question is simply this: why are we hurrying to do this? We need a good nationwide debate. Not two or three weeks. Let’s talk a lot more about this.

June 14th, 2009 at 2:55 pm
You do have a point with regards to foreign doctors. But you must realize that a doctor from India migrating to the US does bnpt necessarily mean that his or her migration is work related