My Channel News

Wednesday, May 20th, 2009

Medical Testing on Animals

Should We Stop Medical Testing on Animals and Start Testing on Humans? lol

Is it essential to have medical testing on animals to make humans lives better? This is an endless debate.

Animal testing is experimenting products ranging from cosmetics, household compounds to pharmaceutical products on the animals before they are approved for human consumptions or usage. There are reports that say 20 million animals are killed annually to support research and animal testing. In many cases it has been found that while testing products, animals are not even administered painkillers and many instances they suffer from serious consequences.

The arguments that are directed against animal testing mainly rest on the ground of moral ethics. There are supporters of animal rights group who argue that it is inhuman to torture animals as no one has right to meddle with the lives of innocent creatures. The reasons that are put forth against animal testing are whether these examinations are at all a necessity or not. The question that arises is the goal for which animal testing is being done is significant or not. Other arguments are that it is not a proven fact that reaction of a drug on animal is identical to that on humans. There are examples which show that a product considered food for animals can be poisonous for humans; sheep, goat, mice and horses consume large quantities of hemlock which is toxic for man and also lime which is so much a must in every kitchen is fatal for cats.

People who have been arguing against animal testing propagate banning it.

However, proponents of animal testing argue the fact that if animal testing will be banned then it would be a blow to medical research and scientific experiments. Innovation for new drugs for human medication and treatment option will become limited and healthcare development will face a serious challenge.

For these animals testing is a great tool for the development of vaccines, antibiotics and hormone replacement therapy drugs and oral contraceptives. Again, it has been argued that painkillers would not have been born if there had been no animal testing. The painkillers are not only used by humans but they are administered even on these living beings. If millions of animals could be slaughtered for consumption and that allowed purportedly, why not allow animal testing for medical research is most of the proponents of animal testing argue.

So with all these arguments the moral dilemma with animal testing continues.

12 Responses to “Medical Testing on Animals”

ruth ARCIERO Says:

Absolutly. ANIMAL TESTING SHOULD BE BANNED PERMANTLY

Kelly Says:

I think its horribly cruel to all animals. Animals have a much higher pain tolerance then humans so It makes my stomach turn to imagine what those poor things must go thru on a daily basis. Animals are the ONLY thing in this world that loves us unconditionaly not even our parents or our children will love us like animals do. I think testing should be done on prisioners that have life sentances…..why not? They have done horrendus things to others and there going to die in prison anyway. What have animals done……

KimK Says:

How difficult is it for human beings to determine that torturing other living beings, and creating suffering and agony in innocent creatures, is WRONG?
When will human beings rise from the most primitive muck of impulses, and self-serving delusion (i.e, believing that other living beings must be tortured to advance human interests..), and aspire to become intelligent, compassionate, and worthy life forms?

“The thinking man must oppose all cruel customs no matter how deeply rooted in tradition or surrounded by a halo.” – Nobel Peace Prize recipient, Dr. Albert Schweitzer

“Ask the experimenters why they experiment on animals, and the answer is:  “Because the animals are like us.”  Ask the experimenters why it is morally okay to experiment on animals, and the answer is:  “Because the animals are not like us.”  Animal experimentation rests on a logical contradiction.”  ~Charles R. Magel

Vivisection is a social evil because if it advances human knowledge, it does so at the expense of human character.  ~George Bernard Shaw

I abhor vivisection with my whole soul.  All the scientific discoveries stained with innocent blood I count as of no consequence.  ~Mahatma Gandhi

John Says:

Should We Stop Medical Testing on Animals and Start Testing on Humans?,…

The Question is a Moot one because the Military and the CIA have been performing Covert experimental testing on Military personal and civilian Populations for many Years.

andy Says:

I think they really should test on humans that are on death row. In other countries, they have “eye for an eye” and it cuts down on the crime rate. Why should innocent animals die when there are plenty of scumbags on death row that have tortured innocent people.

barbara sanderson Says:

two thoughts: totally hypothetically so I can explain my thought. If a superior alien race came to our planet and looked at the human animal as less advanced than them, would they admintister “animal” testing on us and would animal testing be acceptable under those circumstances when “we are the “animal”?

2. I do believe if we currently administered animal testing on humans – death row prisoners, violent offenders, etc., maybe it would deter crime.

MILIS EDMONDS Says:

I THINK THAT WE SHOULD START TO USE PEOPLE (CRIMINALS) IN PRISONS FOR DRUG AND OTHER TESTING. THAT WOULD BE ONE WAY THEY COULD HELP PAY THEIR DEBT TO SOCIETY. WHILE THEY ARE IN PRISON, THEY HAVE NO RIGHTS ANYWAY AND ARE WARDS (PROPERTY) OF THE STATE. I WONDER WHAT “PETA” AND OTHER TREE HUGGING ENVIRONMENTALIST WHACKO-S WILL SAY ABOUT THAT.

avaking Says:

yes, on humans because only humans are capable of informed consent

Donna Says:

Please do not compare a animal to a human.some
thing that will lick it own is not in the same category as a human being.

pm Says:

Start testing on PEA members first.

jp Says:

All PETA members please step to be tested…

Sable Says:

I also want the sadistic torture of animals stopped NOW!

Creatures large and small are filled with love and compassion and empathy; how can anyone even be involved in this?

Though a practice for hundreds of years; as we become aware and intelligent we change things. This is without a shadow of a doubt ONE that Must GO and Change to the release and respect for animals.

Leave a Reply

ADVERTISE HERE: 80X80 Pixels